Does Thinking Count As Writing?

I asked a friend the other day how her writing was going.

“I’m thinking about writing,” she replied. “Does thinking count for anything?”

Thinking of you

Ouch. Sound familiar?

So, you know what I’m going to say, right?

Thinking…well, actually thinking DOES kind of count as writing. (There, did I surprise you? Wait for it…)

But only if you’re doing it in the right way.

(Oo, you knew there was a catch!)

Thinking Kinda Does Count…And It Really Doesn’t

  • Writers need to think — We need copious amounts of thinking time. We need to daydream and imagine and ‘what if’. Happily, we can do this while attending to all those routine brain-free tasks we have to do every day: you know, the ones that keep us clothed and fed and sanitary. (If you’re an adult you know what I mean. If you’re a kid…no, if you’re a kid you won’t even be reading this. You’ll just be writing your first best-seller. Move along.)
  • Beating ourselves up is not productive — unfortunately a lot of writers (especially the ones who aren’t doing any writing) spend a lot of their thinking time fretting about how they’re not writing, not good enough, a lousy person for not doing more actual writing. This is not only unproductive, it is destructive. The best way to stop this kind of thinking in its tracks is to write something — anything. (Keep reading for ideas on what you can write on a day like this)
  • Capturing ideas is useful — sometimes ‘not writing’ means you’re out living. This is a wonderful thing for a writer. You need experience to be able to write anything meaningful. You need to come home and process the stuff that happened to you today, so that it’s there in your brain ready for when you need it. We need to hate people and imagine all the things we should have said to them. We need to love people and freak out when our imaginations show us what life would be like without them. We need to wonder what it would really be like if our plane crashed on a desert island: how would we wash our clothes and what plant fibers could be spun into thread to repair them?
  • Thought vs.  creativity — There will come a time when you need to look at your work with a critical eye, but that time is not during the initial writing phase. In fact, the less you think while you’re writing your first draft the better. Turn off that brain, move your hands and just let the words pour out.

It’s all very well for me to sit here saying this. But how do you actually move from thinking to writing?

You Must Take Action

You have to actually carve out time to sit down and write. Even if you can’t finish a whole chapter. Even if all you can manage is 100 words, 55 words, 140 characters,

DOING something (i.e. writing, crafting a story and characters) is so much better than thinking. Always.

(You may not feel great while you’re doing it, but trust me, afterwards? You’ll feel awesome.)

How To Take Action With Your Writing

It’s easy to get overwhelmed and beat yourself up because you haven’t finished your first novel yet.

Screw that.

  • Set yourself a tiny goal and meet it. Write a twitter fiction story. Write a 55-word story. Write exactly 100 words (no more, no less). Set a deadline. Do the work. Now tell me that didn’t feel good.
  • Use prompts I know it can seem corny but grab a writing prompt and use it for your own purposes. I assigned everyone on my writing course the same prompt one day and you would have been amazed at the radically different stories that came back from 12 different people.
  • Embrace the first draft — Give yourself permission to write something truly dreadful. Tell yourself no-one is going to see it. Picture a baby learning to walk: they fall down, they get up again, they fall down, they get up again, and eventually they are up more than they are down. We learn by doing. We learn by making mistakes. Write something terrible, don’t show it to anyone. Remind yourself the goal is to write something, not to write something good. Not yet.
  • Get an accountability buddy — life comes at us fast. If you’re like me, there’s nobody knocking down your door to hand you a living wage for your fiction yet. It’s easy to let writing slip into the background and — whoosh! — a month has gone by without a single word written. By finding someone to keep you honest, you give yourself the kind of deadlines that you need. You don’t even have to swap writing samples. Just make sure you find someone who will stay on your case and not be too nice to you!
  • So yes, think. Think about your writing. Think about your characters. Think about what you’ll do when you’ve reached your goals.But most of all, keep writing.

    What one thing will you commit to writing this week? How will you make it happen?

    Leave your commitment below, & I will be your accountability buddy for this week (I will personally check up on you on Wed June 22!)

17 thoughts on “Does Thinking Count As Writing?”

  1. Wonderful post! It’s easy to get angry at yourself for doing too much thinking and too little writing but sometimes in order to really get what you want to say down, you need some time to just mull over those ideas.

  2. I love this site. I have spent the last few weeks thinking, not writing, and feeling guilty about it.
    I have picked a great accountability buddy and want (hope) to have a good sized draft done by this time next week! JulieD, you rock!

    1. Fantastic! So glad to hear this. I’m curious about the accountability buddy thing myself. Be sure and check in next week to let us know how it’s going, won’t you?

  3. Julie- I just wanted to let you know one of my flash fiction pieces I wrote in May for your challenge will be published in 2012 with Pill Hill Press Anthology.

    1. Summer, that’s awesome!! I’m a huge fan of Pill Hill Press. What anthology is it – maybe we have stories published in the same book! Is it the Daily Flash 2012?? 🙂

  4. I think too much. I think about writing. I think about thinking about writing. I think, “I should be writing instead of thinking.” It’s been a frustrating several weeks, all this thinking. Tonight, just as I’m getting ready to power down for sleep, I happened to click on my toolbar link to this site. How timely. Thank you, JulieD.

    I don’t tweet. But I do have a couple of writing projects I’ve been pacing around for a while now. One is non-fiction, a 1500 word article on how my local knitting shop bonds strangers and opens doors. The other, a novel still stuck in first draft but I had this major “thinking” breakthrough in the story last week.

    I’ll step up right now, before I shut this computer down for the night, and commit to writing SOMETHING every day on one or the other of these projects. I will make progress each day. I will FB my friends on said progress. And I will check in to see how others are doing.

  5. Excellent start. Try not to overdo it on the first couple of days. Better to pace yourself and actually write a little every day. That way you can really pat yourself on the back at the end of the week.

    I’m excited to see what you come up with. Thanks for making the commitment and I’ll ‘see’ you on Wednesday!

  6. Okay. I kind of look at thinking about writing as sort of like “pre-writing.” But the trick, for me, is to start work on the project before I think myself out of it. It’s really easy to spend so much time thinking about an idea that it starts to sound stupid inside your brain, and then you don’t really want to write about it anymore.

    That happens to me a lot. I find I get stuck in that pattern of thinking/pre-writing and rarely push myself to the pen-in-hand/butt-in-chair level that comes next. It’s not really so much to do with fear, but it just what comes along with having a busy life. For me, writing is the first thing that gets dropped when things start getting hectic. But because I really, truly do have a writer’s heart somewhere inside me, I am always, constantly *thinking* about writing. It’s the one hobby that I’ve never quit. 😉

    So, I guess, the trick is to force myself to carve out some time, even just a precious few minutes to get the words out. (That way, at least, I can move on and think about other things! And “other things” meaning other writing projects, of course!)

    My writing commitment for the next seven days is to find and utilize at least twenty minutes each day to work on a fairy tale retelling that has been entertaining my thoughts the past few days. 🙂 I plan to start tonight when I get home from work. I also pledge to carry my notebook around in my bag with me, too — something I should be doing anyway!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The StoryADay

I, WRITER Course


A 6-part journey through the short story.

Starts July 28, 2023